Open HandWomen, justice and the game

Mothers in Prison: Their Children and Family-Based Treatment Alternatives

Updated

Clay model of a prison visiting room seen from above: a small table with two chairs facing each other, a child-size chair beside one, picture books on the table.

Short answer

Most women in US prisons are mothers: 58 percent of women in state and federal prison had at least one child under 18 in the most recent federal survey.1 Where the children of incarcerated mothers end up, and whether a mother serves her sentence in a cell or in a program with them, depends largely on the state.

On this page (11)

How many mothers in prison have children under 18

The best federal count of mothers in prison comes from the Bureau of Justice Statistics, which surveyed people in state and federal prisons in 2016 and published the parenting results in March 2021. An estimated 57,700 women in prison were the mother of at least one minor child. Mothers in state prison reported 118,300 children under 18, and mothers in federal prison another 13,400.1

Prisons are only part of the picture. Jails hold people awaiting trial or serving short sentences. The Prison Policy Initiative took a Vera Institute of Justice estimate that 80 percent of women in jail are mothers, applied it to the federal count of women in local jails in mid-2019, and arrived at nearly 150,000 incarcerated mothers on a typical day across prisons and jails.2 Its authors flag that the calculation rests on pre-pandemic data.

Many of these women were raising children alone. In the 2004 survey behind an earlier federal report, 42 percent of mothers in state prison said they had lived with their children in a single-parent household in the month before arrest; 14 percent had lived in a two-parent household.3

What happens to the children of incarcerated mothers

When a father goes to prison, the children usually stay with their mother. In the 2004 survey, 88 percent of fathers in state prison said at least one child was in the care of the child’s mother. Incarcerated mothers described a different arrangement. Only 37 percent named the child’s father. Forty-two percent said a grandmother was caring for at least one of their children, 23 percent named other relatives, and 11 percent said a child was in a foster home, agency or institution, five times the rate reported by fathers.3

The 15-of-22-months clock

Foster care brings a federal deadline. Under the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997, a state has to file a petition to terminate parental rights once a child has been in foster care for 15 of the most recent 22 months.4 For a mother serving more than a year or so, that clock can run out while she is still inside.

The statute allows three exceptions. The state may hold off when a relative is caring for the child, when the agency documents in the case plan a compelling reason that termination would not serve the child’s best interests, or when the state has not provided the services the case plan called for to bring the child home.4 A grandmother who takes the children in can therefore give the state a legal reason to hold off.

How often the clock ends a family is hard to measure. An analysis by The Marshall Project found that at least 32,000 incarcerated parents had their parental rights terminated between 2006 and 2019, about 5,000 of them seemingly on the basis of their incarceration alone; a 2021 report by a Yale Law School clinic and Connecticut Voices for Children cites those figures.5 A handful of states, among them New York, Washington and Illinois, have passed laws that help imprisoned parents keep their children, for example by extending the 15-month timeline, and Indiana lawmakers passed a similar bill in 2019.6

Family-based treatment: keeping mothers and children together

Family-based treatment means a residential or community program in which a mother gets addiction treatment, therapy and parenting support while her children live with her or stay closely involved. Some programs house the children; in others, mothers spend time with them in the community instead of behind a fence.7

The model targets a specific group. Mothers Behind Bars, the 2010 report card described below, recommended it for mothers in prison whose offenses were non-violent and tied to an untreated addiction, and argued that this group makes up most women behind bars.7

For evidence, the report pointed to a 2003 evaluation of family residential treatment programs by the federal Center for Substance Abuse Treatment. Six months after treatment, 60 percent of the mothers were completely clean and sober, criminal arrests had dropped by 43 percent, 44 percent of the children had come back from foster care, and employment had risen from 7 percent before treatment to 37 percent.7 Those numbers describe women who went through treatment. They are not a head-to-head comparison with women sentenced to prison.

Access was patchy. The report graded the 50 states and the District of Columbia. In 2010, 34 of those jurisdictions had at least one family-based treatment program, and 32 of them let a court send a woman there instead of to prison. The other 17 had none and received an F.7

Prison nurseries for newborns

A prison nursery is the narrower option. A woman who gives birth in custody keeps her baby with her in a separate unit for a set period. Eligibility is narrow: the 2010 report card found the programs open only to mothers convicted of non-violent crimes with no history of child abuse or neglect. That year it counted 13 states with nursery programs, only two of which let a child stay past the age of two.7

By 2025 the list stood at ten states: California, Illinois, Indiana, Missouri, Nebraska, New York, Ohio, South Dakota, Washington and West Virginia, with Missouri the most recent to open one. Permitted stays run from 30 days in South Dakota to two and a half years in Washington.8 Nebraska’s program at the women’s prison in York dates to 1994 and allows up to 24 months; a 2018 study reported by KCUR found that participants there had a 28 percent lower rate of recidivism and a 39 percent lower rate of returning to prison.8

The report card left nurseries out of each state’s overall grade on purpose. The traits that make a woman eligible for a nursery would also make her a good candidate for serving her sentence outside prison, so the authors treated the nursery as the lesser choice.7

What the 2010 Mothers Behind Bars report card graded

In October 2010 the National Women’s Law Center and The Rebecca Project for Human Rights, a Washington, D.C., advocacy group, published Mothers Behind Bars, a state-by-state report card on pregnant and parenting women in prison.7 It graded every state and the District of Columbia on prenatal care, on policies for shackling pregnant women, and on family-based treatment as an alternative to incarceration.

Averaged across the three, 21 states received a D or F, 22 a C and seven a B. Pennsylvania alone earned the highest composite grade, an A-minus. Thirty-eight states failed on prenatal care and 36 on shackling. The federal Bureau of Prisons was reviewed but not graded; the report noted it ran no prison nurseries.7

The shackling grades and the laws passed since are covered in the guide to shackling pregnant inmates.

Alternatives to incarceration for mothers with children

Another route works at sentencing. Alternatives to incarceration for primary caregivers ask the judge to treat the fact that a child depends on the defendant as part of the sentencing decision, and some states have built a whole sentence around it.

Massachusetts

The 2018 criminal justice reform act added section 6B to chapter 279 of the General Laws. Unless the law requires a prison term, a judge may consider a defendant’s status as the primary caretaker of a dependent child, meaning a parent with whom a child under 18 primarily lives. When the defendant files a motion supported by an affidavit, the court has to make written findings on that status and on alternatives to incarceration.9

Tennessee

Tennessee’s Primary Caregiver Bill was signed by Governor Bill Lee on May 8, 2019, and took effect on July 1 that year. It directs sentencing courts to determine whether a defendant is the primary caregiver of a minor child and, if so, whether the defendant is eligible for an alternative sentence. Felonies involving the use, attempted use or threatened use of physical force or a deadly weapon are excluded.10

Washington

Washington’s parenting sentencing alternative, in RCW 9.94A.655, was enacted in 2010 and broadened in 2020. A parent, expectant parent or guardian whose standard range tops one year can have the prison term waived in favor of 12 months of community custody, with conditions such as parenting classes or treatment. A current violent offense, or a history of sex offenses, serious violent offenses or armed felonies, rules it out. The judge must give great weight to the child’s best interest and can impose confinement if the conditions are broken.11

Oregon

Oregon’s Family Sentencing Alternative Pilot Program, created by House Bill 3503 in 2015, began in January 2016 in Deschutes, Jackson, Marion, Multnomah and Washington counties. It diverted parents facing prison into intensive supervision, treatment and parenting programs. By January 2019, 168 people had taken part, caring for 311 minor children. Children of participants had spent an average of 577 days in foster care against a statewide average of 677, though the agencies cautioned that the sample was too small for firm conclusions.12 In 2025 the legislature passed House Bill 2555, which removed the pilot’s sunset date and made the program permanent.13

Four state sentencing laws at a glance

Sentencing provisions for primary caregivers in Massachusetts, Tennessee, Washington and Oregon
StateLawWho can qualifyWhat the court does
MassachusettsG.L. c. 279, § 6B (2018)Parent with whom a child under 18 primarily livesMay weigh caretaker status; on a motion with affidavit, must make written findings
TennesseePrimary Caregiver Bill (2019)Primary caregiver of a minor child; violent felonies excludedMust determine whether an alternative sentence is available
WashingtonRCW 9.94A.655 (2010, broadened 2020)Parent, expectant parent or guardian; offense-history limitsMay waive prison for 12 months of community custody
OregonHB 3503 (2015), made permanent by HB 2555 (2025)Parent facing a prison sentence, in participating countiesProbation with intensive supervision and family-focused programs

Eligibility is summarized; the statute and the judge decide each case.

If someone in your family is facing a sentence

Families of mothers in prison often meet these rules under time pressure. For advice on a specific case, talk to a lawyer.

Tell the defense lawyer about the children

A sentencing alternative only helps if the judge hears about the children. In Massachusetts the written findings depend on a motion and an affidavit, and in Tennessee and Washington the court has to weigh caregiver status as part of sentencing.9,10,11 The defense lawyer can raise it only after learning it.

Keep the child welfare case in view

If the children enter foster care, ask the caseworker for the case plan in writing and keep a record of every visit, call and letter between mother and children. The exceptions to the 15-of-22-months rule turn on what that plan says and whether the agency delivered it.4

Ask what the prison offers

Ask the state department of corrections whether the women’s prison runs a nursery, extended visits or parenting classes, and what it takes to qualify. Each nursery program sets its own rules on who can take part and for how long.8

Questions about mothers in prison

How many women in prison are mothers?

About 58 percent. The Bureau of Justice Statistics estimated that 57,700 women in state or federal prison in 2016 had at least one child under 18.1

Do incarcerated mothers lose custody of their children?

Not automatically, but it can happen. Once a child has spent 15 of the most recent 22 months in foster care, federal law requires the state to seek termination of parental rights unless an exception applies, such as care by a relative.4

What is family-based treatment?

A program in which a mother receives addiction treatment and parenting support while her children live with her or stay closely involved. In 2010, 32 states allowed courts to use it as a sentence in place of prison.7

Which states have prison nurseries?

Ten as of 2025: California, Illinois, Indiana, Missouri, Nebraska, New York, Ohio, South Dakota, Washington and West Virginia.8

Can a judge consider a mother’s children at sentencing?

Yes, in several states. Massachusetts, Tennessee, Washington and Oregon have provisions for primary caregivers, each with its own eligibility limits.9,10,11,13

References

Sources 13

  1. Parents in Prison and Their Minor Children: Survey of Prison Inmates, 2016
    Maruschak LM, Bronson J, Alper M · Bureau of Justice Statistics, NCJ 252645
    Research Mar 2021 bjs.ojp.gov
    ↩
  2. Prisons and jails will separate millions of mothers from their children in 2022
    Sawyer W, Bertram W · Prison Policy Initiative
    Research May 4, 2022 prisonpolicy.org
    ↩
  3. Parents in Prison and Their Minor Children
    Glaze LE, Maruschak LM · Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report, NCJ 222984 · data from the 2004 Survey of Inmates
    Research Aug 2008 bjs.ojp.gov PDF
    ↩
  4. 42 U.S.C. § 675(5)(E), as added by the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997
    Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
    Legislation 1997 law.cornell.edu
    ↩
  5. Clinic Releases Report on Preserving Parental Rights for Incarcerated Parents
    Yale Law School · Criminal Justice Advocacy Clinic and Connecticut Voices for Children, citing The Marshall Project
    Research Mar 12, 2021 law.yale.edu
    ↩
  6. Indiana safeguards rights of parents in prison
    ABA Journal
    News Apr 26, 2019 abajournal.com
    ↩
  7. Mothers Behind Bars: A state-by-state report card and analysis of federal policies on conditions of confinement for pregnant and parenting women and the effect on their children
    National Women’s Law Center and The Rebecca Project for Human Rights
    Research Oct 2010 prisonlegalnews.org PDF
    ↩
  8. A Nebraska prison nursery keeps moms and babies together. But is there a better way?
    KCUR
    News Jun 10, 2025 kcur.org
    ↩
  9. Massachusetts General Laws c. 279, § 6B, added by St. 2018, c. 69, § 207
    Mass.gov
    Legislation 2018 mass.gov
    ↩
  10. Tennessee Adopts Alternative Sentencing for Primary Caregivers of Minor Children
    Prison Legal News · HB 1449 / SB 985, 2019
    News Aug 6, 2019 prisonlegalnews.org
    ↩
  11. Revised Code of Washington 9.94A.655, Parenting sentencing alternative
    Washington State Legislature · 2010 c 224 § 2; 2018 c 58 § 45; 2020 c 137 § 2
    Legislation 2020 apps.leg.wa.gov
    ↩
  12. Family Sentencing Alternative Pilot Program: Report to the Senate and House Committees on Judiciary
    Oregon Department of Corrections and Department of Human Services
    Government Jan 23, 2019 oregon.gov PDF
    ↩
  13. House Bill 2555, Family Sentencing Alternative Program
    Oregon Legislature · 2025 Regular Session
    Legislation 2025 olis.oregonlegislature.gov
    ↩