Open HandWomen, justice and the game

Shackling Pregnant Inmates: What Federal and State Laws Allow in Labor

Updated

Clay model of a hospital delivery room seen from above: a bed with side rails, an empty newborn cot on wheels beside it, and a chair by the window.

Short answer

Federal law bars restraints on pregnant women held by the Bureau of Prisons or the U.S. Marshals Service, restraints during labor included, from a confirmed pregnancy to the end of postpartum recovery, with narrow exceptions.1 In state prisons and county jails the answer depends on the state, and on whether anyone enforces the rule.

On this page (11)

What shackling means in pregnancy, and why doctors object

In a jail or prison, restraints are handcuffs, leg irons, belly chains and the straps that hold a person to a bed or a seat. Shackling pregnant inmates happens mostly outside the walls: on the drive to a prenatal appointment, on the way to the hospital in labor, and in the hospital room afterward. A 2010 national report card found that some prisons still restrained women in labor and delivery as a matter of course, whatever their history.2

The medical objection is consistent across professions. The National Commission on Correctional Health Care, which accredits health services in jails and prisons, calls restraint potentially harmful to the pregnant person and the fetus throughout pregnancy and after the birth, and especially in labor.3 Its 2025 position statement gives the reasons. Restraints raise the risk of a fall. They get in the way when an obstetric emergency needs fast treatment. After delivery they make it harder to hold and breastfeed the baby, and to move enough to lower the risk of blood clots.

The same statement records that the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), the American Medical Association and the American Public Health Association all strongly recommend against restraints in pregnancy and postpartum.3 ACOG’s current guidance on care in custody is Committee Opinion No. 830, published in July 2021 and reaffirmed in 2024. It replaced the college’s earlier opinions on the subject, Nos. 511 and 535, and holds that people in custody should receive reproductive care by the same guidelines as everyone else.4

The federal rule: what 18 U.S.C. § 4322 says

The First Step Act, signed in December 2018, added section 4322 to the federal criminal code.5 It covers women serving federal sentences, anyone held by the Bureau of Prisons, including in a facility run under contract, and people held by the U.S. Marshals Service.1

How long the protection lasts

The protection starts when a health care professional confirms the pregnancy. It ends when postpartum recovery ends, which the statute sets at 12 weeks after delivery, or longer if the responsible health care professional decides so, and which always includes the whole stay in a hospital or infirmary.1 Within 48 hours of the confirmation, the facility has to tell the woman about these limits.

The two exceptions

Restraints are allowed in two situations. A corrections official or a U.S. marshal may decide that the woman is an immediate and credible flight risk, or an immediate and serious threat of harm to herself or others, and that neither can reasonably be prevented another way. Or the responsible health care professional may decide that restraints are appropriate for her medical safety. Either way, only the least restrictive restraint that deals with the risk may be used.1

What stays off limits even under an exception

No restraint may go around her ankles, legs or waist. Her hands may not be restrained behind her back, four-point restraints are excluded, and she may not be chained to another prisoner. If the health care professional asks for restraints to be removed, or not used at all, the officers must comply.1

Reports and complaints

Each use under the security exception needs a written report within 30 days, sent to the Director of the Bureau of Prisons or of the Marshals Service and to the health care professional. It has to give the reasons, the restraints used, how long, and any physical effects. Both directors certify compliance to the House and Senate Judiciary Committees every year, and the Bureau of Prisons must run a process through which a prisoner can report a violation.1

The federal rule at a glance

18 U.S.C. § 4322 in federal custody (Bureau of Prisons and U.S. Marshals Service)
PeriodRestraints allowed?ExceptionsNever allowed, even then
Pregnancy, from confirmationNoImmediate flight risk or serious threat that nothing else can prevent; medical safetyAnkle, leg or waist restraints; hands behind the back; four-point restraints; chaining to another prisoner
Labor and deliveryNoSame two exceptions, least restrictive restraint onlySame list
Postpartum recovery (12 weeks or longer, whole hospital stay)NoSame two exceptions, least restrictive restraint onlySame list
Any period, when the clinician asksRestraints come offNoneNot applicable

Each use under the security exception must be reported in writing within 30 days.

Before 2018: the Bureau of Prisons policy

The federal prison system changed its own rules a decade before Congress acted. In October 2007 the Bureau of Prisons and the U.S. Marshals agreed to stop using belly shackles on pregnant women unless they could show a security reason.2 In the fall of 2008 the Bureau revised its policy on escorted trips to end routine shackling of pregnant women in all federal prisons, keeping restraints for the most extreme cases.6

An agency can rewrite its own policy at any time. Changing a statute takes Congress. The First Step Act made the rule law, added the restraints that stay off even under an exception, and covered women held by the Marshals Service. A 2021 review by the Government Accountability Office found that pregnant women in Marshals custody spent 68 percent of their time in non-federal facilities such as county jails.7

Shackling pregnant inmates under state law

State prisons and county jails fall outside the federal statute. The research group Advocacy and Research on Reproductive Wellness of Incarcerated People (ARRWIP), based at Johns Hopkins, keeps a state-by-state table of laws on shackling pregnant inmates. As of October 2025 it counts 42 states and Washington, D.C., with laws that restrict restraints during labor and delivery.8

Beyond labor, coverage varies: some laws cover the whole pregnancy, transport and recovery, others start in the third trimester, and postpartum protection runs from 48 hours to 12 weeks. Alaska, Iowa, Kansas and Wyoming are among the states the table lists with no state anti-shackling law at all.8

Illinois

Illinois passed one of the earliest laws, House Bill 1958 in 1999, and amended it in 2012 and 2021. Under 730 ILCS 125/17.5 and 55 ILCS 5/3-15003.6, leg irons, shackles and waist shackles may not be used during pregnancy or postpartum recovery, any restraint must be the least restrictive, and each use on a pregnant person has to be reported in writing to the General Assembly and the Governor’s office.8

New York

Correction Law § 611 dates from 2009 and was widened in 2015. It restricts restraints throughout pregnancy, during transport and for eight weeks after delivery. An exception needs an individualized decision by the superintendent or sheriff, made with the chief medical officer, that restraints are necessary to prevent injury.8

California

California’s rule began with Assembly Bill 2530 in 2012 and was tightened by AB 732 in 2020 and AB 2091 in 2022. It covers pregnancy, transport for delivery and 12 weeks after the birth, bars leg and waist restraints, and keeps custody staff outside the delivery room.8

Texas

Government Code § 501.066 came from House Bill 3653 in 2009 and was amended by House Bill 650 in 2019. It restricts restraints throughout pregnancy and recovery, limits ankle, leg and waist restraints, and lets a mother stay with her newborn for 72 hours after delivery.8

New Jersey

New Jersey’s Dignity for Incarcerated Primary Caretaker Parents Act goes furthest. ARRWIP lists it as the only state law that prohibits restraints outright during pregnancy, labor and delivery, and postpartum recovery, with no security exception.8

The 2010 report card that graded the states

In October 2010 the National Women’s Law Center and The Rebecca Project for Human Rights, a Washington, D.C., advocacy group, published Mothers Behind Bars, a state-by-state report card on how prisons treated pregnant and parenting women.2 It graded each state on prenatal care, on shackling policy and on family-based treatment as an alternative to prison, and scored prison nurseries separately.

On restraints the results were poor. Thirty-six states received a D or F for failing to limit restraints, or to limit them fully, during transport, labor and delivery and postpartum recovery. Only ten states had laws on shackling at the time. Thirty-one had no policy holding institutions accountable for shackling a pregnant woman without adequate justification, and thirty-four did not require each use of restraints to be reported to or reviewed by an independent body.2 One state, Pennsylvania, earned the highest overall grade, an A-minus.

Most of the state laws described above were passed or rewritten after that report. Its grades on family-based treatment are covered in the guide to mothers in prison.

Where enforcement falls short

Laws against shackling pregnant inmates have not always been followed. In New York, the Correctional Association of New York interviewed women who had given birth in state custody after the 2009 law took effect: 23 of the 27 said they had been shackled at least once in violation of it, according to the group’s 2015 report Reproductive Injustice.9

A survey of 22 state prisons and six large jails, run in 2016 and 2017 and published in the Maternal and Child Health Journal in 2023, compared each facility’s stated restraint policy with its state’s law and found inconsistencies. The authors note that no oversight body requires prisons and jails to follow established standards of care for pregnant women in prison.10

Federal custody has been reviewed too. The 2021 GAO report found that the Bureau of Prisons fully matched national guidance on 8 of 16 pregnancy care topics and the Marshals Service on 3 of 16.7

If someone you know is pregnant in custody

What follows is general information about what the laws above make possible for pregnant women in prison or jail. For advice on a specific case, talk to a lawyer.

Make sure the facility knows

Some facilities do not test for pregnancy. ARRWIP advises disclosing a known pregnancy at intake and asking for a test when a pregnancy is suspected.8 In federal custody, the 48-hour notice about restraint limits runs from the confirmation, so the confirmation itself matters.

Get the rules in writing

Ask the jail or prison for its written policy on restraints during pregnancy, transport and recovery, and look up the state statute named in the ARRWIP table.

Bring the clinician in

Under the federal statute, and under the laws of 25 states and Washington, D.C., a health care professional can ask for restraints to be removed and officers have to do it.1,8 A woman in labor, or the family with her, can ask the obstetrician or nurse to make that request.

Write it down and report it

If restraints are used, record the date, the facility, the type of restraint, how long it stayed on, and the names or badge numbers of the officers. In federal custody the Bureau of Prisons must offer a way to report a violation.1 For state prisons and county jails, the ARRWIP table lists the ACLU affiliate in every state, and a civil rights lawyer can explain whether a claim is possible.8

Questions about restraints in pregnancy

Is shackling pregnant inmates still legal in the US?

It depends on who holds the woman. In federal custody, restraints are barred from a confirmed pregnancy through postpartum recovery except for an immediate flight risk, a serious threat or a medical reason.1 In state prisons and county jails the rule comes from state law: 42 states and Washington, D.C., restrict restraints during labor and delivery.8

Can a pregnant woman in federal custody be handcuffed?

Only under one of the two exceptions, and then only with the least restrictive restraint. Her hands may not be cuffed behind her back, and nothing may go around her ankles, legs or waist.1

How long after the birth does the federal rule apply?

Until postpartum recovery ends: 12 weeks after delivery, or longer if the responsible health care professional decides so, and always for the whole hospital stay.1

What was the Mothers Behind Bars report?

A 2010 state-by-state report card by the National Women’s Law Center and The Rebecca Project for Human Rights. It gave 36 states a D or F on their policies for shackling pregnant women.2

References

Sources 10

  1. 18 U.S.C. § 4322, Restraints of prisoners during pregnancy, labor, and postpartum recovery
    Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
    Legislation law.cornell.edu
    ↩
  2. Mothers Behind Bars: A state-by-state report card and analysis of federal policies on conditions of confinement for pregnant and parenting women and the effect on their children
    National Women’s Law Center and The Rebecca Project for Human Rights
    Research Oct 2010 prisonlegalnews.org PDF
    ↩
  3. Nonuse of Restraints for Pregnant and Postpartum Incarcerated Individuals
    National Commission on Correctional Health Care · position statement
    Organization Revised 2025 ncchc.org
    ↩
  4. Committee Opinion No. 830: Reproductive Health Care for Incarcerated Pregnant, Postpartum, and Nonpregnant Individuals
    American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists · reaffirmed 2024, replaces Committee Opinions 511 and 535
    Organization Jul 2021 acog.org
    ↩
  5. First Step Act of 2018, Pub. L. 115-391, § 301 (S. 756)
    Congress.gov · 115th Congress
    Legislation 2018 congress.gov
    ↩
  6. Bureau of Prisons Revises Policy on Shackling of Pregnant Inmates
    ACLU
    Organization Oct 2008 aclu.org
    ↩
  7. Pregnant Women in DOJ Custody: U.S. Marshals Service and Bureau of Prisons Should Better Align Policies with National Guidelines
    U.S. Government Accountability Office · GAO-21-147
    Government Jan 2021 gao.gov
    ↩
  8. Anti-Shackling Legislation and Resource Table
    ARRWIP, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
    Research Oct 2025 arrwip.org PDF
    ↩
  9. Report: Despite Bans, Pregnant Prisoners Still Shackled During Birth
    NPR · on the Correctional Association of New York report Reproductive Injustice
    News Feb 12, 2015 npr.org
    ↩
  10. Shackling and pregnancy care policies in US prisons and jails
    Kramer C, Thomas K, Patil A, Hayes CM, Sufrin CB · Maternal and Child Health Journal 2023;27(1):186–196
    Research 2023 pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
    ↩