Women and justice: guides on prison, pregnancy and the law
What happens when courts and prisons meet pregnancy and motherhood, explained from the statutes, court records and studies behind it.
Updated

Guides in this section
Guide
Shackling Pregnant Inmates: What Federal and State Laws Allow in Labor
The two federal exceptions, the restraints that stay off even then, and the 42 states plus Washington, D.C., with labor-and-delivery laws.
Guide
Mothers in Prison: Their Children and Family-Based Treatment Alternatives
Most women in US prisons are mothers: 58 percent of women in state and federal prison had at least one child under 18 in the most recent federal survey. Where the children of incarcerated mothers end up, and whether a mother serves her sentence in a cell or in a program with them, depends largely on the state.
Guide
Dear Craig: the 2010 letters to Craigslist and what came after
In 2010 two young women who said they had been sold for sex through Craigslist ads as girls addressed open letters to the site’s founder, Craig Newmark, asking him to close its adult services section. By September the section was gone from the US site.
Guide
Prison Nurseries in the US: Which States Let Mothers Keep Their Babies
Ten states had a prison nursery or a residential mother-and-baby program in 2025, and a baby may stay anywhere from 30 days in South Dakota to two and a half years in Washington.
Guide
Parent Sentencing Alternatives: What Each State Law Lets a Judge Do
Parent sentencing alternatives are state laws that make a defendant’s care of a child part of the sentencing decision, either as a factor the judge weighs or as a supervised sentence served at home; in February 2023 the Prison Policy Initiative counted eight states with a caregiver mitigation or diversion law. As of November 2026, Washington and Oregon offer a full community sentence in place of prison for eligible parents, and Oregon’s program has a matched-comparison evaluation.
Where the law meets pregnancy and motherhood
The guides here follow women through custody in the United States: when a jail or prison may restrain a pregnant woman, what happens to the children of mothers in prison, and the sentencing and treatment alternatives that keep a mother and her children together. A further guide covers the 2010 campaign against the adult services section of Craigslist and the federal law that followed it eight years later.
The guides explain the rules in general; for a specific case, a lawyer or a state ACLU affiliate is the place to start.
Restraints during pregnancy: federal and state rules
Federal law has limited restraints on pregnant prisoners since the First Step Act was signed in December 2018. It added section 4322 to Title 18, which covers women held by the Bureau of Prisons, including in contract facilities, and people held by the U.S. Marshals Service.1,2 State prisons and county jails answer to state law; a table kept by the research group ARRWIP at Johns Hopkins counted 42 states and Washington, D.C., with laws restricting restraints during labor and delivery as of October 2025.3
Enforcement is uneven. In New York, 23 of the 27 women interviewed for a 2015 report said they had been shackled at least once in violation of the state’s 2009 ban.4 The guide to shackling pregnant inmates goes through the federal exceptions, the state table and the steps a family can take.
Mothers, children and the sentencing decision
A Bureau of Justice Statistics survey published in March 2021 put the number of imprisoned mothers of minor children at about 57,700.5 When a child spends 15 of the most recent 22 months in foster care, federal law generally requires the state to seek termination of parental rights, unless one of three exceptions applies.6
Some states now ask judges to weigh caregiving at sentencing. In Massachusetts a defendant who is the primary caretaker of a child can ask the court for written findings on alternatives to prison,7 and Oregon made its family sentencing alternative permanent in 2025.8 The guide to mothers in prison compares four such state laws and describes family-based treatment, where a mother lives with her children while she is treated for addiction.
The 2010 report card behind two guides
Two of the guides draw on Mothers Behind Bars, a state-by-state report card published in October 2010 by the National Women’s Law Center and The Rebecca Project for Human Rights, a Washington, D.C., advocacy group. Thirty-six states got a D or F on shackling and thirty-eight failed on prenatal care; many of the state laws in the restraints guide were passed after it.9
The Dear Craig letters and online trafficking
In May 2010 a half-page advertisement in the San Francisco Chronicle, addressed to Craigslist founder Craig Newmark, asked the company to close its adult services section.10 The section came down in early September, and on September 15 a Craigslist representative told a House subcommittee that it would not return.11 In April 2018 FOSTA made clear that section 230 of the Communications Act does not shield websites from federal and state sex trafficking laws.12 The guide to the letters to Craig traces that path.
Reading a statute next to a policy
The guides keep three kinds of rule apart. A statute is passed by Congress or a state legislature and can only be changed the same way. An agency policy, such as a prison system’s rules for escorted trips, can be rewritten by the agency on its own. A jail may also keep written procedures of its own, which can be stricter or looser than the state law above them.
Which of them applies depends on who holds the woman. Section 4322 reaches women in the custody of the Bureau of Prisons or the U.S. Marshals Service. A woman held by a county or a state on state charges falls under that state’s law and the jail’s own policy, whatever the federal statute provides.1
About these guides
Are these guides legal advice?
No. They explain what laws and studies say in general terms. For a specific case, talk to a lawyer or to the ACLU affiliate in the state where the person is held.
How current is the information?
Each guide carries the date it was last checked. It is revised when a law it describes changes or a study it relies on is replaced.
Do the guides cover county jails as well as prisons?
Yes. Where state law applies to both, the guides say so, and they point out where a jail’s own policy can differ from the statute.
Do any US prisons let mothers keep their babies?
Yes, in a handful of states. By 2025 ten states ran prison nursery programs, with stays allowed from 30 days up to two and a half years depending on the state.13
Does the federal shackling ban apply in a county jail?
Only when the woman is held for the federal government, for example by the U.S. Marshals Service. A woman held by the county or the state on state charges falls under state law and the jail’s own policy.1
References
Sources 13
- ↩18 U.S.C. § 4322, Restraints of prisoners during pregnancy, labor, and postpartum recoveryLegal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- ↩First Step Act of 2018, Pub. L. 115-391, § 301 (S. 756)Congress.gov · 115th Congress
- ↩Anti-Shackling Legislation and Resource TableARRWIP, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
- ↩Report: Despite Bans, Pregnant Prisoners Still Shackled During BirthNPR · on the Correctional Association of New York report Reproductive Injustice
- ↩Parents in Prison and Their Minor Children: Survey of Prison Inmates, 2016Maruschak LM, Bronson J, Alper M · Bureau of Justice Statistics, NCJ 252645
- ↩42 U.S.C. § 675(5)(E), as added by the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- ↩Massachusetts General Laws c. 279, § 6B, added by St. 2018, c. 69, § 207Mass.gov
- ↩House Bill 2555, Family Sentencing Alternative ProgramOregon Legislature · 2025 Regular Session
- ↩Mothers Behind Bars: A state-by-state report card and analysis of federal policies on conditions of confinement for pregnant and parenting women and the effect on their childrenNational Women’s Law Center and The Rebecca Project for Human Rights
- ↩Ad accuses Craigslist of prostitutionUPI
- ↩Domestic Minor Sex Trafficking, hearing, Serial No. 111-146 (testimony of William Clinton Powell)U.S. House Judiciary, Subcommittee on Crime, Terrorism, and Homeland Security · GovInfo
- ↩Allow States and Victims to Fight Online Sex Trafficking Act of 2017, Pub. L. 115-164, 132 Stat. 1253GovInfo
- ↩A Nebraska prison nursery keeps moms and babies together. But is there a better way?KCUR