Open HandWomen, justice and the game

Parent Sentencing Alternatives: What Each State Law Lets a Judge Do

Updated

Clay model of a judge’s desk with a closed file folder, a small balance scale and a model of a family house with a lit window.

Short answer

Parent sentencing alternatives are state laws that make a defendant’s care of a child part of the sentencing decision, either as a factor the judge weighs or as a supervised sentence served at home; in February 2023 the Prison Policy Initiative counted eight states with a caregiver mitigation or diversion law.1 As of November 2026, Washington and Oregon offer a full community sentence in place of prison for eligible parents, and Oregon’s program has a matched-comparison evaluation.2,3

On this page (12)

Two ways a law can count a parent

A parent sentencing alternative works in one of two ways. Some laws make the defendant’s children a factor the judge has to weigh before choosing a sentence. Others create a separate sentence, served in the community under supervision, that only parents and caregivers can receive. The Prison Policy Initiative called the first group mitigation laws and the second diversion or priority-access laws, and in 2023 listed Illinois, Massachusetts, California, Louisiana, Oregon, Tennessee, Washington and Missouri.1

The same review found no formal evaluation of the laws as a group and reported that some of the programs behind them were underfunded or had more demand than places, with Seattle and Los Angeles as examples.1 A few states have also passed narrower measures that reach the same families at the moment of arrest or after a prison term has started. Those are covered near the end of this page.

Background on how many mothers in prison have minor children, on family-based treatment and on prison nurseries is in the guide to mothers in prison. This page goes state by state through the statutes themselves: who qualifies, what the court has to do, and what each state has published about results. Related coverage of courts, custody and incarceration is collected under justice.

Massachusetts: written findings on request (G.L. c. 279, § 6B)

Section 6B of chapter 279 defines a dependent child as a person under 18 and a primary caretaker as a parent with whom the child has a primary residence.4 The definition names a parent, so a grandparent raising a child is outside its literal terms.4

Unless a law requires incarceration, the judge may consider caretaker status after a conviction. The defendant can ask for more by filing a motion supported by an affidavit. Once that motion is filed, the court has to make written findings on the defendant’s status as a primary caretaker and on alternatives to incarceration, and it may not impose a sentence of incarceration until it has made them.4

The Prison Policy Initiative described this as the most formal process among the caregiver laws it reviewed.1 Still, the statute does not tell the judge which sentence to choose, and it has no reach over mandatory minimum terms, since it applies only where incarceration is not required by law.4 No published count of how often Massachusetts courts make these findings turned up in the research for this guide.

Tennessee: the 2019 Primary Caregiver Bill

Tennessee’s Primary Caregiver Bill, House Bill 1449 and Senate Bill 985, was sponsored by Senator Brenda Gilmore and Representative Karen D. Camper. Governor Bill Lee signed it on May 8, 2019, and it took effect on July 1.5 The operative word is “shall”: a sentencing court has to determine whether a defendant who is the primary caregiver of a minor child is eligible for an alternative sentence.5

The law lists eleven kinds of community programming a court can draw on. Among them are drug and alcohol treatment, anger management, parenting classes, job training and placement, help finding safe and affordable housing, financial literacy and family case management. Judges keep wide discretion to modify the sentence while it is being served, reductions included, and to impose sanctions within set limits.5

Three groups are excluded: felonies involving the use, attempted use or threatened use of physical force or a deadly weapon against another person, offenses on a statutory exclusion list, and conduct that presents a serious risk of physical injury to someone else.5 When the bill passed, Dawn Harrington, executive director of the Nashville group Free Hearts, told WPLN that Tennessee was tied for third in the nation for the prevalence of children with an incarcerated parent.6

Illinois: parenthood as a factor in mitigation

Illinois wrote parenthood into its list of mitigating factors through the Children’s Best Interest Act, Public Act 101-0471, in effect since January 2020.1 Factor 18 in 730 ILCS 5/5-5-3.1 applies when the defendant is pregnant or is the parent of a child or infant whose well-being will be negatively affected by the parent’s absence.7

The statute lists what the judge should look at: whether the parent is breastfeeding; the child’s age, with strong consideration given to avoiding disruption in the care of an infant, preschool or school-age child; the parent’s part in the child’s schooling and medical care; their relationship; any special medical, educational or psychological needs; the parent’s financial support; the likelihood that the child will become a ward of the juvenile court; and the child’s best interest. Factor 19 covers a defendant who cares for an ill, disabled or elderly relative.7

The defendant also has a right to present a Family Impact Statement at sentencing. It can include testimony from relatives and neighbors, letters, video and documents, and the court has to consider it in favor of withholding or shortening a prison term. Unless the judge finds that the parent poses a significant risk to the community that outweighs the harm of removing the parent from the family, the court must impose a sentence that lets the parent go on caring for the child.7 The law leaves mandatory minimums in place.1

Capacity has lagged behind the statute. The Prison Policy Initiative reported that the state’s Moms and Babies program often had empty places despite demand, and that the Women’s Treatment Center reportedly received only three women from prison over four years before it closed.1

Washington: two parenting alternatives (RCW 9.94A.655)

Washington’s 2010 legislation created two routes. One is a sentence a judge can impose, which the Department of Corrections calls the Family and Offender Sentencing Alternative, or FOSA. The other, the Community Parenting Alternative (CPA), is run by the department for parents already in prison.8 The sentencing statute was amended in 2018 and again in 2020.2

Who qualifies for FOSA

Under RCW 9.94A.655, the high end of the standard range for the current offense has to be more than one year.2 The defendant must be a parent with physical custody of a minor child, an expectant parent, a legal guardian, or a biological or adoptive parent, custodian or stepparent with a proven, substantial relationship with the child that already existed at the time of the offense.2 A current violent offense rules the alternative out, and so does any current or prior felony sex offense, serious violent offense or felony committed with a firearm or deadly weapon. The defendant also has to sign waivers that let child welfare records reach the court.2

What the court does

Before deciding, the court can order a risk assessment that includes a family impact statement. The Department of Corrections must check with the state’s children and families agency for open cases or prior substantiated reports of abuse or neglect, and an open case has to be reported within seven business days. A prior referral does not automatically disqualify the parent.2

If the judge grants the alternative, the prison term is waived in favor of 12 months of community custody, and the court must give great weight to the child’s best interest. Conditions can include parenting classes and treatment, and the department sends the court quarterly progress reports. After a violation the judge can extend the program by up to six months or order confinement within the standard range.2 According to the department, time spent in the community is not credited if the alternative is revoked.8

The Community Parenting Alternative

The CPA lets an eligible parent move from prison to electronic home monitoring for up to the final 12 months of a sentence. A current violent conviction does not bar it. Corrections staff told a state task force in 2022 that prosecutors had objected to giving people with violent offenses an alternative that involves no incarceration at all, the reason FOSA keeps that exclusion.9

What the numbers show

Washington has published counts, not a controlled study. In March 2016 the program administrator told The Spokesman-Review that 274 parents had completed FOSA, that about 68 percent of participants graduated, and that 22 completers, or 8 percent, had committed a new felony, against a 30 percent recidivism rate for the general population.10

In March 2022, Department of Corrections staff told the state’s Criminal Sentencing Task Force that 489 people had entered FOSA, 357 of them (73 percent) had completed it and 132 (27 percent) had been revoked. They added that people who received the CPA were 70 percent less likely to commit a felony than those who did not.9 These figures set program completers against broader groups, so they do not show how much of the difference the program itself produced.

Oregon: from pilot to permanent program

Oregon’s Family Sentencing Alternative Pilot Program began in January 2016 in Deschutes, Jackson, Marion, Multnomah and Washington counties. It diverts parents of minor children who face prison into probation with intensive supervision, treatment and family-focused programs. House Bill 3078 of 2017 removed some of the restrictions on who could take part, for sentences imposed from August 8, 2017.3

By January 2021, 212 people had taken part, 152 women and 60 men, with 391 children between them. State child welfare data from 2020 showed that 91 percent of participants had a child welfare referral or history and 64 percent had an open case at the time.3

In February 2020 the Oregon Criminal Justice Commission compared participants with a matched group of parents outside the program. Among 118 people who had been in the program for at least two years, the predicted three-year rate of recidivism or revocation was 45.3 percent, against 62.5 percent for comparable non-participants, a gap of 17.2 points. Over one year the difference was smaller and less statistically certain, and the commission called its results preliminary.3

House Bill 2555 dealt with the 2025 sunset. As described at a March 2025 hearing, it renames the program, makes it permanent, drops prior criminal history as an automatic bar and lets participants stay for their full supervision period; a proposal to open it to grandparents and other relatives raising children was dropped in a compromise. OPB put participation at about 300 people with roughly 600 children by then, in Columbia, Jackson, Marion, Multnomah and Washington counties.11 The bill passed the House 40 to 0 and the Senate 26 to 3 and was signed in July 2025 as chapter 484 of the 2025 Oregon Laws.12

Parent sentencing alternatives by state

State laws that weigh a defendant’s role as a parent or caregiver, as of November 2026
StateLawWho qualifiesWhat the court does
MassachusettsG.L. c. 279, § 6BParent with whom a child under 18 primarily lives; not where incarceration is mandatoryMay weigh caretaker status; on a motion with affidavit, must make written findings on status and alternatives before any incarceration
TennesseePrimary Caregiver Bill, HB 1449 / SB 985 (2019)Primary caregiver of a minor child; felonies involving force or a deadly weapon and listed offenses excludedMust determine eligibility for an alternative sentence; can draw on 11 kinds of community programs
Illinois730 ILCS 5/5-5-3.1, factors 18 and 19Pregnant defendant, parent whose absence harms the child, or caregiver of an ill, disabled or elderly relativeWeighs listed factors; must consider a Family Impact Statement; must allow continued care unless the parent is a significant risk
Washington (FOSA)RCW 9.94A.655 (2010, amended 2018 and 2020)Parent, expectant parent, guardian or established caregiver; standard range over one year; no current violent offenseMay waive prison for 12 months of community custody with conditions and quarterly reports
Washington (CPA)Community Parenting Alternative (2010)Parent already serving a prison sentence; current violent conviction not a barDepartment of Corrections moves the parent to electronic home monitoring for up to the last 12 months
OregonFamily Sentencing Alternative Program, HB 3503 (2015), HB 2555 (2025)Parent of a minor child facing prison, in participating countiesProbation with intensive supervision, treatment and family programs
CaliforniaPenal Code § 1001.83 (2019)Custodial parent or guardian of a child under 18; serious and violent felonies excluded; county program requiredMay suspend proceedings for 6 to 24 months; charges dismissed on completion
IndianaIC 35-38-1-7.1(b)(10)Any defendant whose imprisonment would cause undue hardship to dependentsMay treat hardship as a mitigating factor; not required to
MinnesotaHealthy Start Act (2021)Person in prison who is pregnant or within eight months of giving birthNo court role; the Commissioner of Corrections may grant conditional release for up to one year of the baby’s life
LouisianaC.Cr.P. art. 223 (2021); HB 264 (2018) not enactedArrested parent or guardian of a minor or dependent childNo sentencing provision; officers should ask about children at arrest and let the parent arrange care

Other states: diversion, hardship and release

California’s primary caregiver diversion, Penal Code § 1001.83, works before conviction. A county’s presiding judge may agree in writing to set up a program.13 Where one exists, a court can suspend proceedings for six to 24 months for a custodial parent or legal guardian of a child under 18 who lives with the child, provides care or support, and whose absence would harm the child.13 Serious and violent felonies are excluded, as are crimes against the child in the defendant’s care. If the parent performs satisfactorily, the charges are dismissed and the arrest is deemed never to have occurred, with exceptions for peace officer applications.13

Indiana has no statute written for primary caregivers. Its general list of mitigating factors lets a court consider that imprisonment would cause undue hardship to the defendant or the defendant’s dependents, and the list is permissive: the judge may weigh the hardship and may also decline to.14 The 2019 Indiana bill for parents in prison dealt with family court, letting judges delay or dismiss the termination of an incarcerated parent’s rights when the parent still plays a meaningful role in the child’s life.15

Louisiana appears on the Prison Policy Initiative’s list of caregiver diversion states, but its 2018 sentencing bill, House Bill 264, drafted by the New Orleans group Operation Restoration, was not enacted.1 In 2021 the state acted at an earlier stage. Act 126 added Article 223 to the Code of Criminal Procedure, under which an arresting officer should, where practicable, ask whether the person cares for a minor or dependent child who may be at risk, let the person arrange care, and make reasonable efforts to keep the child safe.16

Minnesota’s Healthy Start Act of 2021 works after sentencing. The Commissioner of Corrections may conditionally release a person who is pregnant or within eight months of giving birth, for the rest of the pregnancy and up to one year of the baby’s life. In 2025, 12 women were screened and four were on release at some point during the year; two completed it. Six of the eight found ineligible were screened out because of how much time they had left to serve.17

How caregiver status reaches the judge

In each of these states the process depends on information the court may not have on its own. Massachusetts requires written findings only after a motion with an affidavit, Illinois leaves the Family Impact Statement for the defendant to present, and in Washington the judge decides whether to order a risk assessment and a family impact statement before sentencing.4,7,2

Questions about eligibility in a specific case belong with the defense lawyer, and, where children are already in foster care, with the child welfare caseworker as well. The federal clock on termination of parental rights and the family court side of a parent’s incarceration are covered in the guide to mothers in prison, and the rules on restraints for pregnant women in custody in the guide to shackling pregnant inmates.

Questions about parent sentencing alternatives

What is a parent sentencing alternative?

A state law that makes a defendant’s care of a child part of sentencing. Some, like Illinois, add it to the factors a judge weighs; others, like Washington’s FOSA, let a judge replace a prison term with 12 months of supervised community custody.7,2

Which states let a judge consider a defendant’s children at sentencing?

Massachusetts, Tennessee, Illinois and Washington have provisions written for parents or primary caregivers, Oregon runs a family sentencing program, and California offers caregiver diversion before conviction. Indiana lets judges count hardship to dependents as a general mitigating factor.4,5,7,2,3,13,14

Can a parent convicted of a violent offense qualify?

Usually not. Tennessee excludes felonies involving force or a deadly weapon, Washington’s FOSA excludes current violent offenses, and California excludes serious and violent felonies. Washington’s CPA, used near the end of a prison term, is the exception.5,2,13,9

Is Oregon’s family sentencing program still running?

Yes. The pilot was due to sunset in 2025; House Bill 2555 was signed in July 2025 to make it a permanent program.11,12

Do these programs reduce reoffending?

The strongest evidence is Oregon’s: a matched comparison found a three-year recidivism or revocation rate of 45.3 percent for participants against 62.5 percent for similar parents outside the program. Washington’s figures cover completers only.3,10

References

Sources 17

  1. How 12 states are addressing family separation by incarceration, and why they can and should do more
    Emma Ruth · Prison Policy Initiative
    Research Feb 27, 2023 prisonpolicy.org
    ↩
  2. RCW 9.94A.655, Parenting sentencing alternative
    Washington State Legislature
    Legislation Retrieved Nov 2026 apps.leg.wa.gov
    ↩
  3. House Bill 3078 (2017) Report
    Oregon Criminal Justice Commission
    Government Feb 1, 2021 oregon.gov PDF
    ↩
  4. Massachusetts General Laws c. 279, § 6B
    PocketLaw (statute text)
    Legislation Retrieved Nov 2026 getpocketlaw.com
    ↩
  5. Tennessee Adopts Alternative Sentencing for Primary Caregivers of Minor Children
    Ed Lyon · Prison Legal News
    News Aug 6, 2019 prisonlegalnews.org
    ↩
  6. New Tennessee Law Offers Some Caregivers Alternatives To Jail Time
    Meribah Knight · WPLN News
    News May 6, 2019 wpln.org
    ↩
  7. 730 ILCS 5/5-5-3.1, Factors in mitigation
    FindLaw (Illinois Compiled Statutes)
    Legislation Jan 2025 codes.findlaw.com
    ↩
  8. Parenting Sentencing Alternative (PSA)
    Washington State Department of Corrections
    Government Retrieved Nov 2026 doc.wa.gov
    ↩
  9. Sentencing Alternatives Workgroup Meeting Notes, March 8, 2022
    Washington State Criminal Sentencing Task Force · Ruckelshaus Center
    Government Mar 8, 2022 wpcdn.web.wsu.edu PDF
    ↩
  10. Spokane parents get alternative to jail, but victims feel slighted
    Kip Hill · The Spokesman-Review
    News Mar 13, 2016 spokesman.com
    ↩
  11. Lawmakers consider extension of Oregon’s prison time alternative for parents
    Natalie Pate · OPB
    News Mar 28, 2025 opb.org
    ↩
  12. Oregon HB 2555 (2025), bill history
    FastDemocracy (Oregon Legislature record)
    Legislation Retrieved Nov 2026 fastdemocracy.com
    ↩
  13. California Penal Code § 1001.83
    FindLaw (California Penal Code)
    Legislation Jan 2026 codes.findlaw.com
    ↩
  14. Indiana Code § 35-38-1-7.1, Considerations in imposing sentence
    FindLaw (Indiana Code)
    Legislation Jan 2026 codes.findlaw.com
    ↩
  15. Indiana safeguards rights of parents in prison
    ABA Journal
    News Apr 26, 2019 abajournal.com
    ↩
  16. Louisiana C.Cr.P. art. 223, Identification of minor or dependent children upon arrest
    PocketLaw (statute text)
    Legislation Retrieved Nov 2026 getpocketlaw.com
    ↩
  17. 2025 Legislative Report: Healthy Start Act
    Minnesota Department of Corrections
    Government Apr 2026 lrl.mn.gov PDF
    ↩